Intermediary – under GST

Intermediary – under GST


Intermediary – a person who arranges/facilitates the supply between two persons in common parlance.

As per   Act, Intermediary means a broker, an agent, or any other person, by whatever name called, who arranges or facilitates the supply of goods or services or both, or securities, between two or more persons, but does not include a person who supplies such goods or services or both or securities on his own account.


Service Provider: Intermediary/Agent/Broker.

Service Recipient: Any person (In India / Outside India).

Supply: Facilitation of main supply

 


Why is Intermediary service an area of concern for taxpayers? Why do not companies want to be classified as intermediary? Why is it unjust to tax intermediary as per taxpayers?


The Company carrying on business for recipients in non-taxable territory want to buy the reliefs of exports for themselves. If they get classified as intermediary, the place of supply falls in taxable territory by the specific inclusion of intermediary services which many believe to be unjust as the supply is provided to a person outside India and consideration is received in foreign currency.


As per  , the place of the following services shall be the location of supplier of services, namely: –

a) services supplied by a banking company, or a financial institution, or a non-banking financial company, to account holders

b) Intermediary services (Emphasis Applied)

c) services consisting of hiring of means of transport, including yachts but excluding aircrafts and vessels, up to a period of one month.


The moot point being classified as taxable services instead of export of services(zero-rated) which brings the supply liable to GST. Tax treatment by government cannot be said to be unjust because the services become liable to tax. Article 286(2) grants power to Parliament to frame laws to regulate such supplies and accordingly, cannot be said to be unconstitutional. Also, as the service provider is in India there is direct nexus of the services in India.


The vexation being relevant to some extent as Revenue Department brings under the umbrella all transactions with slightest point under the ambit of intermediary services. There are numerous rulings/judgements where the companies are made to pay massive amounts of tax, interest, and penalties due to classification of service as intermediary services at a later stage. It is imperative for companies to capture the transaction as intermediary/non-intermediary at initial stage to avoid litigation.


The dissenting judgement by Bombay High Court in Dharmendra M. Jani Vs Union of India to unfavourable Order by Gujarat High Court in Material Recycling Association of India Vs Union of India and numerous other rulings, brought the need for clarification to stabilize taxation of intermediary service. Circular No.159/15/2021-GST dated September 20, 2021, lays down five checks for intermediary services: –

1. Minimum of three parties

2. Two distinct supply: –

3. Main Supply- between the two principles i.e., supplier and customer

4. Ancillary Supply- between agent and principle i.e., facilitating the main supply

5. Intermediary service provider to have the character of an agent, broker, or any other similar person- i.e., the agent/broker should facilitate the main supply

6. Does not include a person who supplies such goods or services or both or securities on his own account- i.e., a supplier supplying on principle-to-principle basis; and

7. Sub-contracting for a service is not an intermediary service- Where the main supply is sub-contracted and not facilitated between the customers.


Conclusion

Even after clarification by government, the companies need to check whether they will pass the test laid down by the Circular and draft their agreements with utmost clarity to avoid any litigation.


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

GST Reconciliation

Image
GST Reconciliation GST reconciliation stands as a pivotal task for businesses across India, regardless of their scale.  This critical process involves cross-checking GST data extracted from various sources like invoices, purchase orders, and bank statements to guarantee its precision and entirety.  The intricacies of this task often make it time-consuming, particularly for enterprises dealing with high transaction volumes. However, despite its complexities, GST reconciliation remains indispensable. Compliance with GST regulations hinges on this process, crucial for evading substantial penalties.  Moreover, it enables businesses to maintain an accurate financial trail, identifying potential errors or discrepancies along the way. A Proper Explanation of GST Reconciliation GST reconciliation process serves to pinpoint errors or omissions, allowing for timely rectification. The primary objective is to ensure consistency between your recorded invoices and purchases and the data conveyed to
Read more

Understanding E-commerce Operators under GST

Image
Understanding E-commerce Operators under GST In the rapidly evolving world of online commerce, electronic marketplaces have become instrumental in facilitating seamless transactions between buyers and sellers. With the advent of E-commerce, governments worldwide have been adapting their tax systems to keep pace with the digital economy. In India, the GST was introduced on July 1, 2017, and it brought about significant changes for E-commerce operators.  What is an E-commerce Operator? An E-commerce operator refers to any person or entity that owns, operates, or manages a digital platform that facilitates the supply of goods or services between suppliers and customers. Popular E-commerce platforms like MDND, Amazon, Flipkart, and eBay are classic examples of E-commerce operators. These operators act as intermediaries, bringing sellers and buyers together and facilitating transactions. GST Registration of E-commerce Operator E-commerce operators are required to register under GST, regardl
Read more

Show Cause Notices under GST

Image
Show Cause Notices under GST 1. Acknowledgment of Notice • Notice Dates: There may be a difference between the date of the GST notice and the date of its receipt. Always note the date and time when acknowledging the receipt of the SCN. • Avoidance is Not an Option: Ignoring an SCN is not advisable. Receipt and then a response or contestation is the correct approach. Not acknowledging an SCN is considered equivalent to having received it. 2. Responding to Time-Barred Notices • Challenging Time-Barred SCNs: If the service of notice is beyond the permissible period, it can be contested with appropriate evidence. • Extended Time-Period Rule: For SCNs issued after Section 73 timelines, it is essential to demonstrate that there was no concealment or suppression of facts, preventing the department from extending the SCN issuance period to maximum 54 months. The intention to evade tax is mandatory and this has to be proved by the Department. 3. Proactive Measures • GST Payment before
Read more